Skip to content

Good finds only. No prices here: Amazon shows today's price

Gift question · Amazon CA

Gifts for someone who loves holiday baking: 7 tools for cookie season

Guide updated November 22 · by the Foundly team · how we picked

The short answer

For someone who loves holiday baking, the best gifts speed up the December cookie marathon: a Silpat baking mat so shortbread and sugar cookies lift off clean, an OXO oven thermometer to check the oven is really at temperature before tray after tray goes in, and an OXO bent icing spatula for spreading icing and lifting cookies. A Microplane for zest and a cookie scoop for even dough balls are smaller extras that get used all season.

Ad · paid links. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

  1. Silpat baking mat

    Good for: Cookie bakers who go through a roll of parchment every December.

    Holiday baking means a dozen trays in a weekend, and a reusable silicone mat saves tearing off fresh parchment for every one. Silpat invented the mat in France in 1965 and still makes it there from silicone and fibreglass. In olive magazine's test it baked cookies evenly and they lifted off easily, and the diagonally cut corners make it easy to slide out of the pan. Olive concluded that the original is still the best, which makes it the mat to give.

    Skip it if: Their pans are small: this mat is cut for a 13 x 18 inch half sheet pan, so check the pan size first.

    See today's price on Amazon

    Sources: olive magazine

  2. OXO oven thermometer

    Good for: Bakers whose first tray burns and last tray is pale.

    When the oven is opened and closed for tray after tray of gingerbread, its real temperature drifts, and the dial does not say so. An oven thermometer hangs on the rack and shows what is really happening inside. Serious Eats named the OXO Good Grips its best oven thermometer because it stays easy to read even at the back of a rack or behind pans, and its hook grips the rack bars in either direction. It is a small gift that rescues a whole season of cookies.

    See today's price on Amazon

    Sources: Serious Eats

  3. OXO bent icing spatula

    Good for: Bakers who ice sugar cookies, Yule logs and layer cakes.

    An offset spatula has a blade set lower than the handle, so icing goes on smoothly without knuckles dragging through it. Serious Eats lists the jobs it does best: spreading frosting, lifting brownies and cookies off a hot pan, and smoothing the sides of a layer cake. It names this OXO bent icing spatula as another great large offset spatula and an editor top pick. For a holiday baker it moves warm cookies to the rack without breaking them, which matters with delicate shortbread.

    See today's price on Amazon

    Sources: Serious Eats

  4. Microplane fine rasp grater

    Good for: Bakers who add orange zest, fresh nutmeg or grated chocolate to holiday recipes.

    A rasp grater is a long, fine blade on a handle that shaves off zest without the bitter pith, and grates chocolate and hard spices into a fluffy pile. Engadget picks the Microplane over a box grater for zest, cheese and chocolate, and a commenter in r/Cooking, quoted by Tasty, owns two. For holiday baking it turns cranberry orange loaf, gingerbread and hot chocolate toppings into quick jobs. It is a cheap gift that ends up used for dinner too.

    Skip it if: There are small children who help in the kitchen: the blade is very sharp, so store it out of reach.

    See today's price on Amazon

    Sources: Tasty, Engadget

  5. Lodge cast iron double Dutch oven

    Good for: Bread bakers who want a crusty loaf on the holiday table.

    A double Dutch oven is a deep cast iron pot whose lid flips over into a shallow skillet. Home bread bakers like a heavy lidded pot for crusty no-knead loaves, and this one also does a braise for the holiday meal and a skillet breakfast on Boxing Day. In an r/AskReddit thread about life-changing purchases, reported by Mic, a commenter named the Lodge double Dutch oven. Cast iron is a gift that lasts, and it gets better with use.

    Skip it if: They struggle to lift heavy pans: cast iron is heavy, more so when full and hot.

    It is heavy, so expect a large parcel.

    See today's price on Amazon

    Sources: Mic

  6. Cookie scoop

    Good for: Anyone who bakes cookies by the hundred for exchanges and tins.

    A cookie scoop is a spring-loaded scoop that drops equal balls of dough, so every tray bakes evenly and a cookie exchange tin looks bakery neat. A commenter in r/Cooking, quoted by Tasty, said they could not believe they went so many years without one. When the plan is six kinds of cookies before Christmas, it saves a lot of time and sticky fingers. It also portions muffin batter and meatballs the rest of the year.

    We have not matched a specific Amazon.ca listing; any sturdy spring-loaded scoop does the job, and a medium size suits most drop cookies.

    See today's price on Amazon

    Sources: Tasty

  7. Steel bench scraper

    Good for: Bakers who roll out pastry for butter tarts and pies on the counter.

    A bench scraper is a flat steel blade with a handle along one edge. It divides dough, lifts pastry that has stuck to the counter, and scrapes the work surface clean after a day of rolling. In threads quoted by BuzzFeed and Tasty, an r/BuyItForLife commenter said they use theirs all the time and an r/Cooking commenter called it a great way to pick up diced food. For a holiday baker it is the tidy-up tool they will wonder how they managed without.

    We have not matched a specific Amazon.ca listing; a plain stainless steel blade is all it needs.

    See today's price on Amazon

    Sources: BuzzFeed, Tasty

At a glance

PickGood forSkip it if
Silpat baking matCookie bakers who go through a roll of parchment every December.Their pans are small: this mat is cut for a 13 x 18 inch half sheet pan, so check the pan size first.
OXO oven thermometerBakers whose first tray burns and last tray is pale.Nothing we found
OXO bent icing spatulaBakers who ice sugar cookies, Yule logs and layer cakes.Nothing we found
Microplane fine rasp graterBakers who add orange zest, fresh nutmeg or grated chocolate to holiday recipes.There are small children who help in the kitchen: the blade is very sharp, so store it out of reach.
Lodge cast iron double Dutch ovenBread bakers who want a crusty loaf on the holiday table.They struggle to lift heavy pans: cast iron is heavy, more so when full and hot.
Cookie scoopAnyone who bakes cookies by the hundred for exchanges and tins.Nothing we found
Steel bench scraperBakers who roll out pastry for butter tarts and pies on the counter.Nothing we found

How we picked

We pictured a baker in December, turning out tray after tray of cookies, tarts and loaves. The thermometer and spatula come from Serious Eats, the Silpat from olive magazine's mat test, the Microplane from Engadget and Tasty, and the scoop, scraper and Dutch oven from Reddit threads reported by Tasty, BuzzFeed and Mic. We left out stand mixers and big appliances, which bakers like to choose themselves, and cookie cutter sets, which most holiday bakers already own.

Quick answers

What is a good gift for someone who bakes a lot at Christmas?

A Silpat mat and an oven thermometer. Both make a big batch weekend easier, and they get used again next year.

What are good stocking stuffers for a baker?

A cookie scoop, a Microplane or an offset spatula. All are small, cheap and used every time they bake.

What should I get a bread baker for the holidays?

A cast iron double Dutch oven for crusty loaves, and a bench scraper for handling the dough.

Do silicone baking mats fit every pan?

No. The Silpat here is cut for a 13 x 18 inch half sheet pan, so check the size of their pans before buying.

Sources

More gift questions