Skip to content

Good finds only. No prices here: Amazon shows today's price

Gift question · Amazon CA

Toys kids actually play with: 9 picks parents say last past January

Guide updated November 22 · by the Sunnyfound team · how we picked

The short answer

The toys kids actually play with are open ended ones they come back to for years: Magna-Tiles or PicassoTiles magnetic tiles, Calico Critters families and a stack of Play-Doh. Parenting editors also name the Melissa & Doug Scoop and Serve ice cream counter and a Yoto Player for audio stories. For school age kids, a LEGO Creator 3-in-1 Red Dragon builds three different models from one box.

Ad · paid links. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

  1. Magna-Tiles magnetic tiles

    Good for: Toddlers through early school age, and siblings who build together.

    Magna-Tiles are flat plastic shapes with magnets in the edges that click together into towers, houses and garages. Who What Wear called them one of the best investment gifts, and a parent writing there said their child still plays with them every single day. They suit toddlers through early school age, and two or three kids can build together, which is a big reason they keep coming out of the bin year after year.

    Skip it if: A younger sibling still mouths toys: check tiles for cracks, since the magnets must stay sealed inside.

    See today's price on Amazon

    Sources: Who What Wear, Scary Mommy

  2. PicassoTiles magnetic tiles (100 piece)

    Good for: Families who already own some tiles and want a bigger build.

    PicassoTiles are a 100 piece magnetic tile set that does the same job as Magna-Tiles and, according to a parent writing for Who What Wear, works perfectly alongside them. A Scary Mommy parenting editor liked theirs enough to buy a second set. If the family already has a box of tiles, this is the gift that doubles the building, and the big piece count means two kids can build at once without a fight over the squares.

    Skip it if: You are unsure of the age label; magnet toys need a reputable brand and an adult eye on broken pieces.

    See today's price on Amazon

    Sources: Scary Mommy, Who What Wear

  3. Calico Critters animal family

    Good for: Kids who love make believe and small worlds.

    Calico Critters are small flocked animal families with tiny clothes, furniture and houses, and they suit kids who love make believe. A Scary Mommy editor said their family used one set for about eight years and calls it an heirloom toy, and GoodTo's toy guide includes them too. Start with one family this Christmas and add a house later, which also solves next year's birthday present.

    Skip it if: There is a baby in the house: the pieces are small.

    They are sold as Calico Critters in Canada, the same name as in the US.

    See today's price on Amazon

    Sources: Scary Mommy, GoodTo

  4. Play-Doh 10 pack

    Good for: Snow days, kitchen tables and kids of mixed ages.

    Play-Doh is the toy that gets pulled out on a snow day when everyone is stuck inside. A Scary Mommy parenting editor noticed that their kids always return to the simple tubs, even with fancier toys around. A 10 pack of colours is enough for a whole family to share at the kitchen table, and it is cheap to top up when the colours inevitably get mixed into one brown lump.

    Skip it if: The child is younger than the age on the tub.

    See today's price on Amazon

    Sources: Scary Mommy

  5. Melissa & Doug Scoop and Serve ice cream counter

    Good for: Siblings who love playing shop together.

    The Scoop and Serve ice cream counter is a play counter with scoops of ice cream, cones and toppings for running a pretend shop. A Scary Mommy editor said their three kids play with it constantly and the pieces are still in great shape. Pretend shops get played by kids of different ages together, with one serving and one buying, which makes this a good pick for brothers and sisters.

    Skip it if: There is a baby in the house: some pieces are small.

    See today's price on Amazon

    Sources: Scary Mommy

  6. Yoto Player

    Good for: Story loving kids and parents who want a screen free option.

    A Yoto Player is a chunky kids' speaker that plays stories, music and podcasts from cards a child slots in by themselves, with no screen. A Babylist writer said it tops their list of new toys to recommend, and GoodTo lists Yoto starter sets in its toy guide. It suits kids who love stories at bedtime or on long car rides, and parents who want a break from tablets on winter afternoons.

    Skip it if: The family already has a Toniebox and a shelf of figures.

    See today's price on Amazon

    Sources: GoodTo, Babylist

  7. LEGO Creator 3-in-1 Red Dragon

    Good for: School age kids ready for small bricks.

    The LEGO Creator 3-in-1 Red Dragon builds a dragon, a fish or a phoenix from the same bricks, according to GoodTo's toy guide, which notes how cheap it is. That rebuild means a child gets three toys out of one box, and the set is still played with long after the first model is broken up. It suits school age kids who are ready for small parts and like following instructions.

    Skip it if: There are toddlers who might find stray bricks.

    See today's price on Amazon

    Sources: GoodTo

  8. Hot Wheels Track Builder

    Good for: Car mad kids who already own a box of Hot Wheels.

    Hot Wheels Track Builder sets are bendy track pieces and connectors that kids rebuild into new jumps and loops whenever they like, and GoodTo's toy guide picks it for exactly that. A track that runs off the couch and across the living room floor can fill a long winter afternoon. Add it to an existing box of cars for a kid who already loves them, and the old cars get a second life.

    Skip it if: There is a baby or toddler in the house: the cars and connectors are small.

    See today's price on Amazon

    Sources: GoodTo

  9. Disney Pixar Cars die cast set

    Good for: Preschoolers who carry their toys everywhere.

    Small die cast cars are the toy a preschooler carries everywhere, from the bath to the back seat. A Scary Mommy editor said a Disney Pixar Cars set was the most used toy for their nearly four year old. Characters from the films give a child stories to play out, and metal cars survive being dropped, raced and lost under the couch for weeks at a time.

    Skip it if: The child still puts small toys in their mouth.

    See today's price on Amazon

    Sources: Scary Mommy

At a glance

PickGood forSkip it if
Magna-Tiles magnetic tilesToddlers through early school age, and siblings who build together.A younger sibling still mouths toys: check tiles for cracks, since the magnets must stay sealed inside.
PicassoTiles magnetic tiles (100 piece)Families who already own some tiles and want a bigger build.You are unsure of the age label; magnet toys need a reputable brand and an adult eye on broken pieces.
Calico Critters animal familyKids who love make believe and small worlds.There is a baby in the house: the pieces are small.
Play-Doh 10 packSnow days, kitchen tables and kids of mixed ages.The child is younger than the age on the tub.
Melissa & Doug Scoop and Serve ice cream counterSiblings who love playing shop together.There is a baby in the house: some pieces are small.
Yoto PlayerStory loving kids and parents who want a screen free option.The family already has a Toniebox and a shelf of figures.
LEGO Creator 3-in-1 Red DragonSchool age kids ready for small bricks.There are toddlers who might find stray bricks.
Hot Wheels Track BuilderCar mad kids who already own a box of Hot Wheels.There is a baby or toddler in the house: the cars and connectors are small.
Disney Pixar Cars die cast setPreschoolers who carry their toys everywhere.The child still puts small toys in their mouth.

How we picked

We kept toys that parents and parenting editors say their own children still play with months or years later, from Scary Mommy's editors, Who What Wear, Babylist and GoodTo's toy guide. Open ended toys won over single use gadgets and anything that relies on a fad. We left out screens and ride on toys. Check the age label on every listing, since several of these have small parts or magnets.

Quick answers

What toys do kids play with the longest?

Open ended ones: magnetic tiles, small figure families, Play-Doh and building sets. They can be played a different way each time.

Are magnetic tiles a good gift for toddlers?

Follow the age label, buy a reputable brand and check tiles for cracks, since the magnets must stay sealed inside.

What is a good screen free gift for kids?

A Yoto Player for stories and music, or a pretend shop like the Melissa & Doug ice cream counter.

What toy suits a snow day indoors?

Play-Doh, a Hot Wheels track or a big box of magnetic tiles.

Sources

Deal of the day, by email

Get one good find a day

One hand picked find in your inbox each day, with the reason it made our list.

We keep your email, your store and when you said yes. Privacy

More gift questions